Toy & card shops in Hyannis, MA

In and around Hyannis, shops cover toys, comics, puzzles, plush, LEGO, trading cards, board games, and models.

In Hyannis, Vanguard Tabletop Gaming is a game store at 795 W Main St with board games, trading cards, and models. It lists Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh, Lorcana, Warhammer, Dungeons & Dragons, and Star Wars, and it offers events. Corner Toy Store in Chatham is a comic shop at 507 Main St in business since 2012; it lists Star Wars and carries plush, comics, and puzzles, with an online store.

Cape Cod Toy Library, Inc. in Barnstable is at 1919 Main St #6a and carries puzzles; it offers classes or workshops, open play tables, and events. Village Toy Store in Brewster is at 1069 Main St, lists LEGO and Calico Critters, and carries plush, puzzles, and crafts; it offers events. Red Balloon Toy Shop in Orleans is at 114 Rt 6A, has been in business since 1970, lists LEGO and Playmobil, and carries plush, board games, puzzles, and crafts.

5verified shops

3shop types

1deep profiles

2026-10-30last checked

#1Toy shop

Cape Cod Toy Library, Inc.

1919 Main St #6a, Barnstable, MA(508) 648-3227Website

Cape Cod Toy Library, Inc. is an independent toy store in Barnstable, MA. It offers classes or workshops, open play tables, events.

Categories: puzzles

#2Comic shop

Corner Toy Store

507 Main St, Chatham, MA(508) 945-0334Website

Corner Toy Store is an independent comic shop in Chatham, MA. The shop lists Star Wars. It offers online store. It has been in business since 2012.

In business since: 2012

Categories: plush, comics, puzzles

#3Game store

Vanguard Tabletop Gaming

795 W Main St, Hyannis, MA(508) 258-9439Website

Vanguard Tabletop Gaming is an independent game store in Hyannis, MA. The shop lists Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh, Lorcana, Warhammer, Dungeons & Dragons and more. It offers events.

Categories: board games, trading cards, models

#4Toy shop

Village Toy Store

1069 Main St, Brewster, MA(508) 896-8185Website

Village Toy Store is an independent toy store in Brewster, MA. The shop lists LEGO, Calico Critters. It offers events.

Categories: plush, puzzles, crafts

#5Toy shop

Red Balloon Toy Shop

114 Rt 6A, Orleans, MA(508) 255-4208Website

Red Balloon Toy Shop is an independent toy store in Orleans, MA. The shop lists LEGO, Playmobil. It has been in business since 1970.

In business since: 1970

Categories: plush, board games, puzzles, crafts

Toy Shops and Open Play

Cape Cod Toy Library, Inc. is at 1919 Main St #6a in Barnstable and lists puzzles. It offers classes or workshops, open play tables, and events. Village Toy Store is at 1069 Main St in Brewster; it lists LEGO and Calico Critters and carries plush, puzzles, and crafts. The shop offers events. Red Balloon Toy Shop is at 114 Rt 6A in Orleans. It has been in business since 1970, lists LEGO and Playmobil, and carries plush, board games, puzzles, and crafts. These shops cover puzzles, plush, crafts, LEGO, Calico Critters, and Playmobil, plus open play and events at these shops.

Comics, Cards, and Tabletop Games

Corner Toy Store is at 507 Main St in Chatham. It is a comic shop in business since 2012, lists Star Wars, carries plush, comics, and puzzles, and offers an online store. Vanguard Tabletop Gaming is at 795 W Main St in Hyannis. It is a game store with board games, trading cards, and models. The shop lists Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh, Lorcana, Warhammer, Dungeons & Dragons, and Star Wars, and it offers events. Together these shops cover comics, plush, puzzles, board games, trading cards, models, and the listed game and comic brands.

Questions people ask

Which shops offer events?

Cape Cod Toy Library, Inc. in Barnstable offers events with classes or workshops and open play tables. Vanguard Tabletop Gaming in Hyannis offers events. Village Toy Store in Brewster offers events. These three shops list events.

What can I find at Village Toy Store and Red Balloon Toy Shop?

Village Toy Store in Brewster lists LEGO and Calico Critters and carries plush, puzzles, and crafts; it offers events. Red Balloon Toy Shop in Orleans has been in business since 1970, lists LEGO and Playmobil, and carries plush, board games, puzzles, and crafts.

Where can I find comics and trading cards?

Corner Toy Store in Chatham is a comic shop at 507 Main St; it lists Star Wars, carries plush, comics, and puzzles, and offers an online store. Vanguard Tabletop Gaming in Hyannis carries trading cards and lists Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh, Lorcana, Warhammer, Dungeons & Dragons, and Star Wars.

Sources for this guide

Every shop fact was extracted from the shop's own website or a structured-data record on it, with a verbatim quote. Address and category data also come from the Overture Maps places dataset (CDLA-Permissive 2.0).

Shop by category in Hyannis

Toy stores (5)

Nearby guides

Illustration for the Boston toy shop guide

14 shops