Toy & card shops in Chillicothe, OH

Chillicothe shops cover models, trading cards, and collectible figures, with online, consignment, trade-in, and event services.

Illustration for Chillicothe

Chillicothe has independent shops for models, trading cards, and collectible figures. The History Store at 99 N Paint St is a toy store with a models category; it offers an online store, consignment, and events. W. Britain Toy Soldier & Model Figure Company at 20 E Water St is a collectibles shop with a models category; it offers trade-ins and events. Total Gaming Experience at 617 1/2 Central Center is a card and game shop with a trading cards category; it offers buy and sell, open play tables, and events. Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store is in Circleville; it is a hobby shop with a board games category, lists Warhammer, and offers events.

For models, two Chillicothe addresses are The History Store and W. Britain Toy Soldier & Model Figure Company. Both list models as a category and events as a service. The History Store also lists an online store and consignment; W. Britain lists trade-ins. For trading cards, Total Gaming Experience lists buy and sell and open play tables. Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store lists board games and Warhammer and offers events.

4verified shops
4shop types
0deep profiles
2026-11-02last checked
Illustration of The History Store
#1Toy shop

The History Store

99 N Paint St, Chillicothe, OH(740) 775-7400Website

The History Store is an independent toy store in Chillicothe, OH. It offers online store, consignment, events.

Categories: models
Illustration of Total Gaming Experience
#2Card shop

Total Gaming Experience

617 1/2 Central Center, Chillicothe, OH(740) 656-7860Website

Total Gaming Experience is an independent card and game shop in Chillicothe, OH. It offers buy and sell, open play tables, events.

Categories: trading cards
Illustration of W. Britain Toy Soldier & Model Figure Company
#3Collectibles

W. Britain Toy Soldier & Model Figure Company

20 E Water St, Chillicothe, OH(740) 702-1803Website

W. Britain Toy Soldier & Model Figure Company is an independent collectibles shop in Chillicothe, OH. It offers trade-ins, events.

Categories: models
Illustration of Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store
#4Hobby shop

Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store

203 Lancaster Pike, Circleville, OH(740) 497-4145Website

Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store is an independent hobby shop in Circleville, OH. The shop lists Warhammer. It offers events.

Categories: board games

Model shops with online, consignment and trade-in services

The History Store at 99 N Paint St is an independent toy store in Chillicothe. Its category is models. It offers an online store, consignment, and events. W. Britain Toy Soldier & Model Figure Company at 20 E Water St is an independent collectibles shop in Chillicothe. Its category is models. It offers trade-ins and events. Both addresses are in Chillicothe, OH. The two shops give model shoppers two Chillicothe places to visit: one toy store with an online store and consignment, and one collectibles shop with trade-ins. Each offers events as a service.

Card, board game and hobby shops with events

Total Gaming Experience at 617 1/2 Central Center is an independent card and game shop in Chillicothe. Its category is trading cards. It offers buy and sell, open play tables, and events. Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store at 203 Lancaster Pike is an independent hobby shop in Circleville. Its category is board games. It lists Warhammer and offers events. The two shops address different parts of the card and game hobby: Total Gaming Experience covers trading cards with buy and sell and open play tables, while Puma's Rest covers board games and Warhammer. Both offer events as a service. Total Gaming Experience is in Chillicothe; Puma's Rest is in Circleville.

Shop mix

Toy shop
1
Card shop
1
Collectibles
1
Hobby shop
1

Trends stocked here

No brand-level trend match yet for this city.

Read next

The Fad Report

One email a week, measured.

Index movement, one city with three shops, and the drops and recalls worth knowing. Double opt-in; leave any time.

Questions people ask

What can I find at The History Store?

The History Store is at 99 N Paint St in Chillicothe, OH. It is an independent toy store whose category is models. The shop offers an online store, consignment, and events. The address is in Chillicothe, and the category is models.

Where can I find open play tables for trading cards?

Total Gaming Experience at 617 1/2 Central Center in Chillicothe is an independent card and game shop with trading cards as its category. It offers buy and sell, open play tables, and events. The shop's services include buy and sell and events as well as open play tables.

What does Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store offer?

Puma's Rest, Your Local Game Store is at 203 Lancaster Pike in Circleville. It is an independent hobby shop whose category is board games. It lists Warhammer and offers events. The shop is in Circleville, OH, and its category is board games.

Sources for this guide

Every shop fact was extracted from the shop's own website or a structured-data record on it, with a verbatim quote. Address and category data also come from the Overture Maps places dataset (CDLA-Permissive 2.0).

Nearby guides

Illustration for the Columbus toy shop guide
5 shops

Toy & card shops in Columbus, OH

Columbus-area shops for toys, games, comics and cards, with play tables, tournaments, parties, consignment and trade-ins.